Skip to content Menu

The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) found three key limitations of the composite score the Department of Education uses to assess the financial health of institutions that participate in the federal student aid programs. In report GAO-17-555, published on September 20, the GAO called the score an imprecise risk measure, arguing that it had predicted less than half of school closures since the 2010-11 academic year.

The limitations included:

  • Failure to reflect updates in accounting practices.
  • Use of outdated financial measures rather than new metrics such as liquidity, historical trend analysis, or future projections.
  • Vulnerability to manipulation by allowing schools to inflate their scores by taking out additional debt.

The GAO also criticized ED for inadequately explaining how it calculates schools’ composite scores, noting that administrators at seven out of the 10 schools analysts consulted were confused about their calculations. NACUBO staff met with GAO investigators during their examination and shared concerns about shortcomings in ED’s methodology and application of its rules.

The watchdog agency recommended that ED:

  1. Update the financial composite score to better measure schools’ financial conditions.
  2. Improve its guidance to schools on how it calculates the composite score.
  3. Provide public data on final composite scores for all schools.

In its formal response to the GAO, ED disagreed with the first recommendation even though it is in the process of establishing a negotiated rulemaking committee to update the composite score calculations in light of accounting changes.


Sue Menditto

Senior Director, Accounting Policy



Liz Clark

Vice President, Policy and Research


Related Content

NACUBO Updates Student Agreement Language to Address Assessment of Collection Fees

NACUBO’s updated advisory, Best Practices for Student Financial Responsibility Agreements, includes model language for the agreements and addresses court decisions affecting the ability of an institution to recover costs associated with collections, among other topics of interest to business officers.

NACUBO Tuition Discounting Study

The annual NACUBO Tuition Discounting Study (TDS) measures the institutional tuition discount rates and other indicators of institutional grant awards to first-time, full-time first year undergraduates and all undergraduates who attend private, nonprofit (independent) colleges and universities.

In Comments, NACUBO Disagrees with GASB’s Compensated Absence Proposal

Proposed liabilities for nonvested sick leave do not meet the definition of a liability, NACUBO recently wrote to the Governmental Accounting Standards Board.